Decisions only you can make

Everything below survived adversarial review and now needs an owner's call. Where the principles already point somewhere, the recommendation is marked — say "agreed" or override. Full evidence for each lives in RESEARCH.md (Parts I–IV, §6 of each).

The three that shape the product

Decision 1 · the biggest

Fixed-clock nap as the product, or onset-anchored?

The original vision was onset-anchored everything. The evidence: sensor noise on onset detection (±13–33 min) is wider than the whole nap decision, while a fixed ~20 minutes lying down works for everyone on day one and automatically shortens your sleep when you take long to drift off — "errors land early" by structure.

Recommendation: fixed-clock is the product; onset detection becomes an invisible refinement that can only shorten a nap, never extend it. This is your works-fully-or-not-offered rule applied honestly.

Decision 2

Do the coaching surfaces ship at all?

Nap-window advisories, evening warnings, bedtime nudges, debt bands — individually defensible, but assembled they are Rise with an alarm attached: the tracker you rejected, arrived at by accretion.

Proposed rule: anything that renders when no alarm is set is out of scope. Keeps invisible calibration and the deadline/buffer disclosure; cuts most of the rest. Yes or no on that rule.

Decision 3

Is the niche worth validation-grade engineering?

The gap is real — nobody combines onset-aware naps + nights + haptic wake + guaranteed deadline + free. But the category's entire visible demand is ~30 app ratings, Apple ships sleep features yearly, and your rule demands measured accuracy before claims. The research tells you exactly what it costs to make the product true; whether that's worth it is strategy, not evidence.

No recommendation — genuinely your call.

Product promises & honesty

Scope conditions & disclosures

Smaller calls

Phone-only mode (Part III)

Oura & WHOOP integration (Part IV)

How to answer: a single message like "agreed on all recommendations except…" is enough. Anything you don't override ships as recommended, per the project's decision rule.
← Path to MVP Back to Overview Smart Wake